Short Story ◉ Philosophy

What Is the Act of Deciding in a Decision?

Ren, Haru, and Mio consider the essence of decision. Not just choosing options, but what makes a decision a decision.

  • #decision
  • #choice
  • #responsibility
  • #will
  • #freedom

"A decision is choosing an option, right?"

Haru said casually.

Ren shook his head. "That's a superficial understanding."

"Huh?"

"A decision isn't choosing. It's deciding."

Haru was confused. "Aren't they the same?"

Mio said quietly, "Different."

Ren began explaining. "Selecting from options is choice. Decision goes beyond that."

"How does it go beyond?"

"By accepting irreversibility."

Haru pondered. "You mean you can't go back?"

"Yes. Decision involves resolve."

Mio nodded slightly. "Responsibility."

"Exactly," Ren said. "A decision is the act of accepting responsibility."

Haru asked, "But choice also has responsibility, right?"

"It does. But the quality is different," Ren answered. "Choice is reversible. Decision is irreversible."

"Reversible?"

"You can redo it. Bread or rice for breakfast, you can choose again. But marriage or divorce, you can't choose again."

Haru understood. "The gravity is different."

"Gravity and temporality," Ren supplemented. "Decision defines the future."

Mio said quietly, "Binding."

"Binding?" Haru asked.

Ren interpreted. "Decision binds your future. But that is also freedom."

"That's contradictory."

"Kierkegaard's paradox," Ren said. "Freedom is born through decision."

"Why?"

"Possibility alone realizes nothing. Decision makes possibility into reality."

Mio added, "Leap."

"Leap?"

Ren nodded. "A leap of faith, Kierkegaard said. Decision beyond reason."

Haru asked anxiously, "Beyond reason? Isn't that dangerous?"

"It is dangerous," Ren admitted. "But all decisions involve uncertainty."

"If you had perfect information, would decisions be easy?"

"Easy, or rather, unnecessary," Ren answered. "With perfect information, options narrow to one."

Mio said quietly, "Decision, amid uncertainty."

"Exactly," Ren smiled. "Decision is the courage to accept what you don't know."

Haru had another question. "So is hesitation weakness?"

"The opposite," Ren said. "Hesitation is proof you see multiple possibilities."

Mio nodded. "Thought."

"Those who decide without hesitation aren't thinking, or don't see options."

Haru felt relieved. "It's okay to hesitate."

"However," Ren continued, "continuing to hesitate is avoiding decision."

"Avoiding?"

"Bad faith, Sartre criticized. Postponing decision."

Mio said quietly, "Not deciding is also deciding."

Haru was surprised. "Even doing nothing?"

"Yes," Ren explained. "There's no neutrality. By not deciding, you're choosing the status quo."

"You can't escape responsibility," Haru murmured.

"Can't escape," Ren acknowledged. "That's the human condition."

Mio asked, "Regret?"

"Regret is unavoidable," Ren answered. "Attachment to the path not chosen."

Haru became anxious. "So how should I decide?"

"There's no perfect decision," Ren said. "But there are better decisions."

"How?"

"Based on values. What you hold important."

Mio smiled faintly. "Know yourself."

"Yes," Ren nodded. "Decision requires self-awareness."

Haru took a deep breath. "Difficult, but unavoidable."

"Unavoidable," Ren repeated. "But that creates life."

Mio said finally, "Decision, accumulation."

"Accumulation," Haru murmured. "Each one creates me."

Ren said quietly, "Decision is the act of deciding yourself. What you choose determines who you become."

The three sat quietly. Thinking of the countless decisions they would make.